Skip to main content

Lessons One Should Learn From Shehla Sherin's Death

If you do not avoid news like me, you would have heard about the tragic death of a 10 year old in Wayanad a couple of days ago. You can search the name and find the story on your own, but a few facts are established already.

  1. Shehla Sherin had her foot go into a hole on the floor of her classroom and was afraid a snake bit her in that incident
  2. There was delay in taking her to the hospital
  3. Anti-Snake venom was not administered at the local hospital, and the child was referred to a tertiary care center at least an hour away.
  4. Child died on the way.
I won't unnecessarily go into speculations on what other things happened on that fateful day, but having managed emergency department in a rural hospital for over an year, I will use this sad death to illustrate two very important lessons for every doctor.

Lesson 1: Never take any complaint lightly, even if the circumstances lead you to think otherwise

There are two ways patients can come in. There are people who exaggerate, and people who downplay. Take all symptoms seriously.

There are no insignificant complaints. There are no insignificant findings. Whatever the patient tells you has to be taken seriously. Even if the patient asks you to not take it seriously. At the height of experience and confidence you might be able to predict that something isn't as serious as it sounds, but be really really careful before making that decision.

I had once a patient come to the casualty with a swollen foot. The patient had intellectual and speech disabilities and therefore there was no proper history. The bystander (who apparently takes care of the patient) told that "someone must have hit him". My colleague suspected a snake-bite because of the way the swelling looked, but nevertheless ordered a whole blood clotting time test and a foot x-ray to rule out a fracture. My shift was about to start and while I was taking charge from my colleague I inspected the foot of this patient closely (in the x-ray room). I could see two small points of bleeding close to each other - fang marks!

We immediately told the bystander that this is not "someone must have hit him", it is a snake bite, and that the patient will die unless something is done immediately. This bystander did not look like they liked the patient very much because they asked me "please do whatever you can here itself, don't refer us to higher center". We knew that the best we could do was given anti-snake venom (which we immediately started doing) but the patient might require blood products which weren't available and required referral. So, we took a stand and sent the patient as soon as the ASV went in.

There was this other patient who came at noon on a different day with severe chest pain, as if he was going to die the next moment. He was a smoker and alcoholic with a very good chance of having a heart attack. He wouldn't even lay still for us to get a proper ECG, and whatever leads we could obtain looked like there were ST elevations all over. The MI protocol kicked in, we gave all the painkillers, anti-coagulants, and sent the patient to the nearest cardiology center. News later was that he was just having severe gastritis due to alcoholism. But, we did what we should have done.

We've had a patient with vague headache/chest pain admitted for observation die on us under strict observation. I've had a patient with diarrhea go into dehydration and shock. I've had a lady who could perceive fetal movements but have no fetal heart activity on ultrasound. We've had a person with cellulitis of lower limb go into septic shock and die while we were on rounds. We've had a bystander who missed anti-epileptic medication die after getting seizures and aspirating. I've examined a kid with high fever who had febrile seizure on the way out. We've had a kid admitted for being dull after vaccination die in front of us, despite our best efforts. We've had a child in waiting area who wasn't breathing well arrest by the time they were identified by a patient care worker to be requiring urgent attention. I've had a patient with vague thigh pain turn out to be deep vein thrombosis and die next day.

Always have the worst outcomes in mind when making decisions. Be mindful about patients who you haven't even seen yet. Communicate a lot. Err on the side of cautiousness.

Never be afraid to wake seniors up from sleep. When in doubt, ask for help. If you are not sure about something, check it again. If something happens while you could have done something which you didn't, you'll regret that your entire life. And that is a pain.

Lesson 2: It is a privilege to have access to the miracles of modern medicine. When you have the power to use things, please also have the courage to.

There is always going to be a risk. It is risk that makes the work of a doctor exciting. If you've chosen to be a doctor, there is no way you can avoid risk. Even if you become a dermatologist, you can land up in soup. As a doctor, the only way to avoid risk is by quitting professional life and meditating inside a cave.

Risks shouldn't hold you back from attempting something that's required for your patient. I got this lesson the first time when I was still an intern, and was in KR Hospital's Medical ICU. I was trying to insert a catheter into someone's jugular but I was going too superficial. My senior then told me "Always remember, what you're doing is for the benefit of the patient. You're only going to harm them by not doing it confidently. The patient will die if they don't get this line. So you may as well put it in boldly."

There is a definite role for experience and knowledge in being able to build the confidence to do things. But neither of that will come unless you want to do those things for your patient. If you are shy of cutting, you can never be a surgeon. If you are scared of side effects, all the pharmacology you know is absolutely of no use.

Too many doctors think that by not committing something they're keeping themselves safe. But their fake sense of safety comes at the cost of the patient's suffering. Laws of medical negligence apply to acts of omission as well as they apply to acts of commission. With all your training you may as well do something and fail, than be a mean coward. That's what your license is for.

Use anesthesia (ketamine + midazolam, if you will) when draining breast abscess. Give powerful analgesics when people are in pain (don't give diclofenac for MI/fracture. Give something like pentazocine). Use second line and third line drugs when the first line fails. Give aminophylline or magnesium sulphate for COPD/Asthma. Steroids and immuno-suppressants are in various guidelines for a reason - use them when indicated. Even newborns may need anti-epileptics. Benzathine Penicillin is the best available cure for Syphilis. "Higher antibiotics" are not reserved for higher centers. Use vasopressors (and for heart's sake not fluids) in hypotension where failure needs to be considered. Use nitroglycerine to control high blood pressure. Use heparin. Use atropine. Use adrenaline. Use BiPAP. Resuscitate. Use oxygen. Use fluids. Give vaccines. Conduct deliveries. Splint fractures. Suture large wounds. Intubate and bag till the ventilator in referral center. Use all the things you've learnt to deliver care. That's why you're a doctor.

And if you feel you're under-prepared for any of those things even after MBBS, work with sincere people in rural hospitals (like VMH or THI or BHS). Learn the skills. Learn the craft. Understand pain and suffering. Care for other humans. Become a good doctor. Then do whatever you want to.


I had a rule when I was working in ED - "Nobody dies when I'm on duty". The only exception was patients admitted for palliative care. Imagine if every doctor in our country made rules like that for themselves.


Dr.Dinesan said…
Dear Dr.Akshay,

Thank you for such an eye-opener ,

But different situations may need different modus operandi (like in corporate hospitals, treatment without proper diagnostic procedures may take you tobtroubles. Off course in a life n death situation your practical wisdom in managing the patient and common sense in managing the crowd(convincing) are equally
Important. Good
Arjun said…
Great it

Popular posts from this blog

What Can an Individual Do?

Forwarding a message I received from Dr Dharav Shah who is creating a wave of change in youngsters across India making them abstaining from the first puff and the first drink so they lead a healthy and happy life without the poisons we love.
Do watch the video. I had tears only once, but your mileage may vary.
Dear friends,
Last week i had forwarded TEDx talk of Dr Taru, who had worked in a district hospital of Bihar. The NGO with which she was working, needs doctors for similar work in district hospitals in Bihar.
If you know any surgeon, Gynecologist, pediatrician or Anaesthetist who would probably like to take up this challenge for 6 months or more, please inform them about this opportunity to contribute. Please forward this ad in your medico groups
Are you upto the challenge of being an agent of change, working towards improving Emergency services in a progressive Bihar?
1. WHO-CARE Global Surgery fellowship - *Specialist Obstetrician*:

Understanding Adrenaline Dosage

Have you ever administered adrenaline for anaphylactic shock? I've never had the unfortunate need to. I'm sure anyone who ever does will forever remember the correct dosage. But for me, it is always a confusion. Every time I vaccinate someone at my clinic, I look up the dose of adrenaline just to be sure.

The first problem is the dilutions. Dosages of adrenaline are (or were) mentioned in dilution. 1:1000 & 1:10000. There begins the confusion.

Firstly, let us understand where the 1000 comes from in 1:1000. Have you seen a small vial of adrenaline? That is 1mL. It has effectively 1mg of epinephrine/adrenaline. But why is it called 1:1000? Because 1mL of water = 1g of water = 1000mg. So, the 1:1000 actually refers to 1mg of adrenaline : 1000 mg of water. Unnecessarily complex!

All you had to say was 1mg in 1mL. And that is why this labeling is now being followed in some countries.

So, there you have a small vial - a 1mL vial - with 1mg of adrenaline in it.

Now, let us look a…

Why is Benzylpenicillin called Penicillin G and Phenoxymethylpenicillin Penicillin V?

This one took a lot of searching. My initial hunch was that the G and the V stood for amino acids. G for Glycine and V for Valine. I thought, maybe, if these amino acids were not substituents, at least they would be the precursors involved in synthesis of Penicillins. I had also heard the word "Penicillin Gold" somewhere suggesting that they could be acronyms as well.

After some searching around, there was a chance discovery of this page on some encyclopedia that said "The different forms of penicillin are distinguished from each other by adding a single capital letter to their names. Thus: penicillin F, penicillin G, penicillin K, penicillin N, penicillin O, penicillin S, penicillin V, and penicillin X"

Now I knew there are more letters and these are chosen just because they are in the alphabet and not because of anything special. So the question became, why these letters? Did they start with Penicillin A and go down all the way till Penicillin V and even X? Is…

Interactive textbook with adaptive level of complexity

This is an idea I've been having since a long time. I think it is relatively easy to implement as well.
We need textbooks like we have online maps. Textbooks that give you an overview first and then let you zoom in to any part and get more and more details. The deeper we go and the more details we have the harder will the level of complexity be. So, a beginner can probably zoom out and get a large overview of all the topics they need. Someone who already has the overview can zoom in at a part and get some more details. Then, they can zoom in again and get more details, and again, and again till they reach the maximum available information.
Writing such a textbook may seem complicated but all it takes is some amount of reorganization of thoughts and marking sentences by their level of complexity.