Skip to main content

Healthcare in Consumer Protection Act 2019, VP Shantha and why you should read the source

There are good journalists and bad journalists. It is the reader's duty to discern between what is right and what is wrong. The problem in the 21st century is that that duty is completely thrown into water under the guise of "forwarded as received".

There are a lot of articles in newspapers talking about dropping the world "healthcare" from the list of services under the consumer protection act of 2019. Many of them have fancy headlines suggesting that healthcare will not be a service that falls under the ambit of the new consumer protection act. At least some of them have written objectively stating where the word is dropped from without going into judgement on what this means.

But many doctors are reading headlines and thinking that the consumer protection act will not apply to healthcare henceforth. What they need to read to know they are wrong is just one judgement by the Supreme Court in the "Indian Medical Association vs VP Shantha, 1995" case.

That judgement was specifically about settling the question of whether healthcare is a service that falls under the definition of service as defined in the consumer protection act (the act of 1986). For ease of reference I will quote the definition from the old act:

" "service" means service of any description which is made avail­able to potential users and includes, but not limited to, the provision of  facilities in connection with banking, financing insurance, transport, processing, supply of electrical or other energy, board or lodging or both, housing construction, entertainment, amusement or the purveying of news or other information, but does not include the rendering of any service free of charge or under a contract of personal service;"

Notice that healthcare is not specifically mentioned. Supreme Court read this definition and confirmed that healthcare is included in the broad definition of "service of any description" and spelled out conditions where it would be excluded.

Now, here is the definition from the new act:

""service" means service of any description which is made available to potential users and includes, but not limited to, the provision of facilities in connection with banking, financing, insurance, transport, processing, supply of electrical or other energy, telecom, boarding or lodging or both, housing construction, entertainment,amusement or the purveying of news or other information, but does not include the rendering of any service free of charge or under a contract of personal service;" (emphasis for words that have been added)

Where is the "healthcare" word dropped from then? Well, it is from the draft bill that was introduced.

Now you can read the full judgement on how the new definition also includes healthcare in it.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

"Risks" vs Risks

Decision making is almost always complicated by uncertainties. The more information that can provide context, the more stakeholders that are part of the decision, the better the chances of reaching a good decision.

In the past few weeks, world leaders have had to make very difficult decisions. Lock down entire country? Put money into healthcare? Risk economic disasters to prevent health disaster?

I guess the biggest problem they would have faced in making these decisions is uncertainty. Because medicine is a field of uncertainties. The first thing a doctor learns when helping patients is that they can never be sure of anything other than the fact that they have to act. Diseases, cells, organisms, molecules, environment, human behaviour - there are a lot of moving parts in medicine. Parts that you can't control. Parts that you can't even predict.

A doctor is a performance artist who uses an imperfect science to help alleviate suffering. In Osler's words, "Medicine is …

Anatomy paper 1 RS 2 RGUHS 2013 December question paper

My roommate says this one was easy too.

Pharmacology RGUHS question papers December 2012

Try solving these

Lessons One Should Learn From Shehla Sherin's Death

If you do not avoid news like me, you would have heard about the tragic death of a 10 year old in Wayanad a couple of days ago. You can search the name and find the story on your own, but a few facts are established already.

Shehla Sherin had her foot go into a hole on the floor of her classroom and was afraid a snake bit her in that incidentThere was delay in taking her to the hospitalAnti-Snake venom was not administered at the local hospital, and the child was referred to a tertiary care center at least an hour away.Child died on the way. I won't unnecessarily go into speculations on what other things happened on that fateful day, but having managed emergency department in a rural hospital for over an year, I will use this sad death to illustrate two very important lessons for every doctor.

Lesson 1: Never take any complaint lightly, even if the circumstances lead you to think otherwise There are two ways patients can come in. There are people who exaggerate, and people who down…