Skip to main content

Science is Broken Because Scientists Can't Think Rationally

Scihub is being sued in Indian courts by the journal industry. There are some people worried about it. But it is funny how our knowledge system works. Take this tweet for example:

The reason why journals charge exorbitantly and still get away with it is because almost all academicians publish only in those journals. And why do academicians publish in those journals? Here comes the greatest hypocrisy/logical fallacy of academicians.

They think that publishing in "prestigious" journals bring "prestige". They even have a way of measuring prestige without making it sound like it's an emotional thing - impact factor. It is all part of the same logical fallacy - argument from authority. A cognitive bias that makes humans think that "authority" is right.

The only purpose of journals in the internet age is to exude authority.

The same purpose of universities.

If scientists step down from their pedestals and start looking at the world without bringing in their cognitive biases (like every scientist should be doing), there can be a world where knowledge is produced and consumed with lesser hurdles.

There definitely is a side to this where the omnipresent, omnipotent "system" is oppressing academicians and forcing them to continue with this prestige based publication. After all, scientists are humans who would rather give in to the way the world works than stand up against anything.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Product Idea: "Explain My Prescription To Me" Service

Many doctors have very little time to spend with the patient. So little time that sometimes they start writing prescription before even arriving at a provisional diagnosis. Imagine how then, would they explain to their patient why they have written a particular tablet for them? Is there a product/service idea in this vacuum of counseling that should have been provided by the doctor? Are there people who are not able to ask the right questions to the internet to find the answers? Perhaps there should be an app that is front-end for a prescription description service. The user uploads their prescription and also attaches a short voice note with their symptoms. This goes to a doctor/nurse/pharmacologist/pharmacist at the back-end who responds by reading out the prescription and counseling the patient about what the medication is, what it does, what side effects can be expected, etc. The counseling of each medicine can be recorded and reused for the next patient who is prescribed the

Meftal-Spas vs Meftal-Forte for Menstrual Pain

I was recently asked by someone whether Meftal-Forte is a better drug than Meftal-Spas for menstrual pain. I hadn't heard about Meftal-Forte till then. So I looked up. 1mg told me both the drugs are manufactured by Blue Cross. The page about Meftal-Spas gives us what I knew already - it is a combination of Mefenamic Acid 250mg and Dicyclomine 10mg. The page about Meftal-Forte told me that it is a combination of Mefenamic Acid 500mg and Paracetamol 325 mg. Based on this, the quick answer is "No. Meftal-Spas seems to be better suited for menstrual pain in people who find relief by using it. But self-medication may not be the best way to manage menstrual pain." The longer answer is that dicyclomine is an anti-spasmodic that is widely used with anecdotal evidence supporting its use in primary dysmenorrhea. Mefenamic acid is an anti-inflammatory drug that is indicated for use in primary dysmenorrhea. Paracetamol is not really indicated for primary dysmenorrhea. Th

What Doctors Don't Get to Study in Medical School by BM Hegde

Disclaimer: I realize that I could be putting myself in great academic danger by publishing this post while studying medicine in the same state of the honoured author. But whoever decides to influence my very open professors and make me fail in my exams, also please read this response by nirmukta to one of his articles, to realize that I'm not the only person who feels like there's stone in the rice, waiting to be bitten. Ah! What an interesting title and how easy a way to grab the attention of a medical student tired of reading pharmacology. Within minutes of starting to read this book, I could smell honest but blind religiosity. With all due respect to the degrees the author possesses, this book isn't worth buying. But you should definitely read it once, to understand the workings of a conspiracy theorist's mind. If you read with a truly open mind, you will be able to ignore the blatant errors of facts or practicality and focus on the drive home mes

Lumbar Puncture and HIV

Lumbar puncture is a fascinating procedure. It is cheap, it can be done in relatively remote places, and it can be learnt easily given access to enough people who need it. LP has an incredible role in the management of many complications related to HIV. I've heard stories about how there used to be 5 LPs done every day in VMH during the time when HIV was causing rampant destruction in Karnataka and India. When I was there, we would do about 5 in two weeks. Nevertheless, when a colleague asked on Twitter about CSF analysis, I thought I should write down some of the things I believe to know about Lumbar Puncture itself, especially in relation to its use in management of complications of HIV. The first many LPs I saw were all done for spinal anesthesia in KR Hospital. Till then all I knew about spinal anaesthesia was a friend's description of the back ache he had post a "cool" hernia surgery because they had "poked many times for anaesthesia". I think I hadn&#